Do we value things more before or after putting in effort to get them? New research published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General says it depends on when the effort happens.

The study found that people tend to devalue rewards that require future effort, but once the effort is already spent, the same reward suddenly becomes more valuable. This shift in perception says that timing—whether effort lies ahead or behind—plays a very important role in how we assess the worth of an outcome.

The experiment: Mug vs. money

Researchers tested this theory using a simple but clever setup: participants had to choose between receiving a fixed amount of cash or a mug, but with a twist. To get the mug, they had to do physical effort equivalent to walking up one to three flights of stairs.

In some cases, the effort was hypothetical and lay in the future. In others, participants were told they had already made the effort. This helped researchers see how the same physical task changed the perceived value of the mug depending on when it occurred.

The results? When the effort was in the future, most people saw it as a cost—they preferred the cash. When the effort was in the past, many saw it as an investment, making the mug seem more valuable.

Interestingly, the study also showed that not all minds work alike. Researchers found four distinct patterns in how individuals respond to effort:

Effort-averse: For some, more effort always reduced the perceived value.

Effort-driven: Others consistently placed a higher value on the item when effort was required to obtain it.

Timing-sensitive: Some devalued future effort but appreciated past effort.

Indifferent: A small group showed little change in valuation based on effort.

These findings offer insight into everything from consumer behavior to motivation at work and decision-making in everyday life. Whether it’s buying something online, choosing a workout, or completing a tough project, the way we view the value of an outcome is often tied to how we think about the effort involved—and when.

So next time you wonder if something is worth it, remember: your answer might just depend on whether the hard part is still ahead—or already behind you.

 

You might also be interested in - Women can naturally hear better than men and have more sensitive ears: Study