As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes more common in everyday life, many people are curious about its role in healthcare. Deepak Shenoy, CEO of Bengaluru-based CapitalMind, recently shared his experience of using AI to analyse his health report. His story has sparked a debate—can AI replace doctors?
How can someone rely on AI for health advice?
Shenoy explained in a post on X that he entered his MRI report into ChatGPT. The AI chatbot advised him not to do deep squats, which made sense to him since he had been training for them. He had been experiencing knee pain, and after visiting his doctor, he was asked to get an MRI scan. When he fed the report into ChatGPT, the AI detected a slight knee displacement, suggesting a possible sports-related injury.
“I will meet the doctor and get treatment, but I found this information very interesting," Shenoy wrote.
His post received many responses, with some users sharing their own experiences. One person said, “I also gave my ultrasound report to ChatGPT, and it gave me better advice than the doctor."
Is AI a reliable medical tool?
While some users praised AI for providing helpful insights, others warned against relying too much on it. One user cautioned, “AI-based self-determination is not right. Advice should be taken only from doctors who treat real cases every day."
Medical experts agree that AI can be a useful tool in healthcare, but it cannot replace doctors. AI can analyse reports and provide possible explanations, but it lacks the deep understanding and hands-on experience of human medical professionals. Relying only on AI for medical decisions can be risky, as it might not consider all aspects of a person’s health.
For now, AI may serve as a helpful assistant in analysing reports, but when it comes to treatment and critical decisions, doctors remain essential.
Experts say that AI can be helpful in healthcare, but it cannot take the place of doctors. AI can read reports and suggest possible explanations, but it does not have the knowledge and experience that real doctors do. Depending only on AI for medical advice can be risky because it might miss important details about a person’s health.
Right now, AI can be a useful tool to understand reports, but when it comes to actual treatment and important medical decisions, doctors are still necessary.
You might also be interested in: Man demands half of father’s body in bizarre dispute over last rites