On September 4, 2024, the Himachal Pradesh Assembly enacted a pivotal legislative measure designed to limit the financial advantages granted to Members of the Legislative Assembly (MLAs) who switch allegiance from their respective parties. The new bill by Himachal Pradesh, titled the Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly (Allowances and Pension of Members) Amendment Bill 2024, proposed by Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu, establishes that any MLA disqualified under the anti-defection law will forfeit their entitlement to pension benefits.

The newly enacted legislation clearly articulates that "A person shall not be entitled to a pension under the Act if they have been disqualified at any point under the tenth schedule of the Constitution," which addresses the anti-defection law. This legislative amendment aims to deter party-switching and foster loyalty among elected representatives.

New bill by Himachal Pradesh
Image Source: Digit Insurance

The Role of the New bill by Himachal Pradesh in Reinforcing Constitutional Mandates

This bill was introduced following the disqualification of six Congress MLAs earlier this year, who faced penalties for disregarding a party directive during critical budget discussions. The disqualified MLAs, Sudhir Sharma, Ravi Thakur, Rajinder Rana, Inder Dutt Lakhanpal, Chetanya Sharma, and Devinder Kumar, also endorsed a BJP candidate during the Rajya Sabha elections, exacerbating existing tensions within the state's political arena. While Sharma and Lakhanpal successfully reclaimed their positions through by-elections, the remaining four were unable to return to the assembly.

The introduction and enactment of this bill illustrate the persistent political turmoil in Himachal Pradesh, particularly concerning party discipline and the financial consequences of defection. The primary objective of the bill is to uphold democratic principles by safeguarding the electorate's mandate and preventing breaches of the constitution.

The statement of objects and reasons accompanying the amendment emphasizes the necessity for such legislation, pointing out deficiencies in the existing provisions of the 1971 Act, which have not effectively deterred defections. By eliminating pension benefits for disqualified MLAs, the government aims to strengthen the significance of party loyalty and discourage opportunistic political actions.

This legislative initiative has elicited mixed responses from various political factions. Supporters contend that it is an essential measure to preserve integrity within the political framework, whereas detractors may perceive it as a punitive action that could suppress dissent within political parties. The passage of this bill represents a proactive strategy by the Congress-led government in Himachal Pradesh to confront the issues arising from political defections and to reinforce party discipline.

You might also be interested in - Himachal to use FDR technology for the first time in road construction, reducing costs by 80%